
IELTS Writing Task 2: Discuss Both Views Without Losing Your Position
“Discuss both views and give your own opinion” contains three jobs. Explain the first view, explain the second, and make your position clear. An essay that praises one side while briefly naming the other leaves part of the task unfinished.
IELTS's official guidance emphasises interpreting the actual prompt rather than forcing it into a memorised essay. A structure is useful when it helps you develop the requested argument. It becomes a problem when it determines the argument before you have read the question.
Identify the disagreement precisely
Try this original practice prompt: “Some people think secondary-school students should complete a group project in every subject. Others think most assessed projects should be individual. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.”
The disagreement concerns how assessed projects should be organised. An essay about whether schools are generally useful would miss the focus. So would a response that discusses teamwork only in workplaces.
Before drafting, write a short label for each position: regular group assessment versus mainly individual assessment. Keep those labels visible as you plan.
Give each view a reason worth examining
Supporters of group projects might argue that students learn to coordinate contributions and respond to other people's ideas. An original example could be a science investigation where students divide data collection and then agree on an interpretation.
Supporters of individual projects might argue that the final work reveals each student's understanding more clearly. An example could be an individual history essay in which every student must select and justify evidence.
These are possible arguments for this fictional prompt, not research findings about which approach produces better results. Their usefulness lies in explaining the reasoning behind each view.
Develop rather than accumulate
A paragraph that lists collaboration, confidence, communication and creativity can remain superficial. Choose one central reason, explain how it operates, and use an example to make the mechanism clear.
For the group-work paragraph, you might explain that dividing tasks is not enough: students must reconcile conflicting interpretations. That gives your claim substance. For the individual-work paragraph, explain why separate submissions make unequal understanding easier to see.
The example should illuminate the reason. It does not need a fabricated percentage, named study or invented expert.
Make your position consistent
You could favour mainly individual assessed projects while supporting selected group projects where collaboration is itself a learning goal. That is a clear position if you explain the distinction and keep it consistent.
A suitable introduction could briefly identify the debate and state that balance. The body should show why you reached it, and the conclusion should restate the same judgement. Changing to “all projects should be group projects” at the end would undermine the argument.
Balanced discussion does not require pretending that both views are equally persuasive. It requires representing them fairly before justifying your judgement.
Check the instructions before the language
For this prompt, ask: have I explained both views, given an opinion and supported it? Then check paragraph progression, vocabulary precision and sentence accuracy.
Task 2 requires at least 250 words and contributes twice as much as Task 1 to the Writing score. Those requirements make complete task coverage worth protecting during planning.
Try Newton's IELTS Academic Writing practice test for manual assessment after submission. Feedback and bands are practice estimates rather than official IELTS results.
Sources
IELTS: Academic Writing test format. The prompt, arguments and planning examples are Newton originals.



Comments