top of page

Teaching Similes and Metaphors: Go Beyond Naming the Device

Oct 17
3 min read

A child can correctly identify a metaphor and still have little idea what it contributes to a sentence. Naming the device is a starting point. The more interesting work is explaining what is compared, which qualities matter and how the comparison changes the scene.


England’s English curriculum connects figurative language with meaning and effect. The home routine below develops that connection through short original examples. It is not a list of phrases to memorise and insert into every story.


Begin with the ordinary meaning


Read this original sentence: The corridor was a freezer after the heating failed. Ask what happened literally. The corridor became very cold; it did not turn into a kitchen appliance.


Then ask what the comparison adds. Freezer suggests a stronger, more uncomfortable cold than the corridor was cool. The detail about failed heating supports that reading. We call this a metaphor because the corridor is presented as something else to make a comparison.


Change the sentence to The corridor was like a freezer after the heating failed. This is a simile: the comparison is made explicitly with like. The shared feature remains coldness. Switching the label does not automatically create a different meaning or a better sentence.


Ask which qualities transfer


A freezer is also a container that preserves food, but the sentence does not require every quality of a freezer to apply. Help the learner select the features that make sense in context rather than building an unrestricted list of associations.


Try another original line: Her explanation was a key to the puzzle. The useful connection is that an explanation makes understanding possible, as a key can make something accessible. It does not tell us that her explanation was metal or could fit in a pocket.


Ask the child to complete this frame in their own words: The writer compares ___ to ___, suggesting ___. The frame is temporary support. Once the reasoning becomes clear, the child can explain the effect naturally without reciting the same formula.


Do not confuse a comparison with an interpretation


The phrase uses a simile is a label. It makes the scene interesting is too general to explain much. A stronger response to the corridor example is: Comparing the corridor to a freezer emphasises how unpleasantly cold it became after the heating failed.


Accept more than one plausible interpretation when the words support it. Some comparisons are deliberately ambiguous. Equally, do not praise every imaginative suggestion as if evidence were optional. Ask: Which part of the sentence helped you think that?


Choose a comparison for a purpose


For writing practice, begin with a plain observation: The small lamp helped me find the doorway. Ask what feeling the scene should create. Relief? Fragile hope? A sense of welcome? Then try a comparison that serves that intention.


An original possibility is The lamp was a small island of light in the dark hallway. Discuss whether island suggests separation and safety here. If the story needs a brisk, practical tone, the plain sentence may actually be the better choice.


Avoid setting a quota such as three similes in every paragraph. That can reward decoration rather than judgement. One well-chosen comparison may do more than several that compete or point in incompatible directions.


Return to the sentence after discussing it


Read the original line aloud again. Ask the learner to explain it without the technical term, then with the term if useful. This checks whether the vocabulary is attached to understanding.


A short conversation about one effective comparison is enough for a home session. The aim is to help a child think like a reader and writer: attend to language, test a possible meaning and make a deliberate choice.


Sources



Related Newton reading




Comments


Newton Learning System

bottom of page